Home / News / Towards Contested Collective Intelligence

Towards Contested Collective Intelligence

As society’s problems get only more complex (not just more complicated), there is growing interest in how we can blend “the cloud with the crowd” — the best of machine intelligence and human intelligence. Specifically, complex, wicked problems are never resolvable by individuals analysing a problem and announcing the solution. Multiple perspectives are needed, and engaging stakeholders in helping to define the problem, never mind deciding what might count as an acceptable solution, is critical.

Collective Intelligence (CI) is the name given to efforts to demonstrate that, when done well, groups or even casts of hundreds/thousands of citizens, can work more effectively on a problem than individuals. Internet platforms provide cost effective ways to harness the crowd. As we speak, teams are competing in the IARPA CREATE competition, to build the best online platform that can harness the expertise of a team of volunteer citizens.

I was invited by one of the CREATE contestants, the University of Melbourne’s SWARM Project (Smartly-assembled, Wiki-style Argument Marshalling), to spend the day with them, discussing how they are tackling this challenge. For over 20 years, I’ve been exploring the design of a specific class of CI platform, dubbed Contested Collective Intelligence. These are designed around the principle that in wicked problems, people will disagree as much as they agree, and it is important for computer systems to be able to work with that. Read more on the CIC Knowledge Cartography page.

The SWARM team’s approach looks to be very promising, and could have exciting applications for teams of students in educational contexts. If the future is collective intelligence, today’s students need to be learning how to work with each other around such tools. The good news is that the SWARM platform will be released open source. Track their news and sign up if you want to participate.

Meantime, here is my distillation of 20 years work into a series of dilemmas and (partial) solutions… (PDF version), which I’ve been blogging over the years under the tags collective intelligence and argument mapping.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.